Obsolete College Professors Thursday, Oct 19 2006
A colleague pointed out an op-ed piece from the Lawrence Journal World in Lawrence, Kansas titled Libraries are limited, obsolete by Mark Hirschey.
Dr. Hirschey is a Professor of Economics and Finance at the University of Kansas.
In the op-ed, Dr. Hirschey decries the expense of building a new Library for the town of Lawrence, Kansas. Dr. Hirschey thinks that Libraries are obsolete because people can find what they want on the Internet and they don’t need a Library.
I think he raises a few points that Libraries and Librarians need to market their resources and be accessible to their patrons. But I also think that Dr. Hirschey is confused to think that everyone could find everything on the Internet. Publishers don’t put their materials on the Internet for free - someone has to pay for it. Libraries pay those fees to buy books, purchase access to databases of articles and reports and they make the materials available to their patrons.
I notice on Dr. Hirschey’s cv that he is a published author - well he is a tenured professor with a PhD and the rule is publish or perish. I guess he does get paid for the articles that he writes and the occasional book he edits or publishes. If Libraries didn’t buy these items - who does he think would? Well, his students would since I’m sure his books and articles are required reading for them.
Sure I use the Internet to find lots of information - but I also know where to look. Sometimes I connect via the Internet to a resource such as ProQuest with which my Library has contracted database services.
Of course - any time I need to know about business and economics - I look up the answer on Wikipedia and I know that it’s 100% always reliable!